• RLW

  Rabbi L. Wineberg`` -11 years ago

  terms
  I'll work on it bl"n

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

• M

  Michale -11 years ago

  Great class
  Thank you, Rabbi, for very good class. I would like to ask somebody in your team to make all definitions / cases available in written form (Ivrit / English), such as pdf-file. It will good for memory and understanding.

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

• YB

  Y Berson -11 years ago

  Who Began muktzeh
  Rabbi Wineberg,
  
  
  
  Who began muktzeh? You spoke of Dovid and Shlomo. But who was the first to invent these laws?
  
  
  
  Also, Can I move my flower vase in middle of the meal on Shabbos to another location?
  
  
  
  Also, when the leichter are done, and the candles are out, can I move them to another place?
  
  
  
  Also, if I have a desk and in its drawers are pens, printing paper, writing paper, wallet, batteries, tools, check books, scissors, and also some letters or plain papers, can I open the drawer on Shabbos?
  
  
  
  How about can I open my kitchen drawer which has tape, batteries, pens, things that we don't use on Shabbos, but it may also have a come or brush which I want to use on shabbos? And what if it has only tools and pens inside, may I open the drawer on Shabbos?
  
  
  
  Also, is a picture or painting on the wall muktzeh?
  
  
  
  And one last question, may I brush off my hat from dust on Shabbos with a hat brush?
  
  
  
  Thanks for great classes.

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

  • RLW

    Rabbi L. Wineberg -11 years ago

    Re: Who Began muktzeh
    In his shulchan Aruch ch308:17 the Alter Rebbe writes that non-utensils (stones for example) were already forbidden "in the days of Dovid and Shlomo 'or earlier' ". At any rate in the story about Shlono that was related in the intro, we see that Shlomo was not innovating but was following  a well-established practice.
    
     I have not found any speci fic chochom named as the innovater of muktzah.

    Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

Levi Wineberg

• August 29, 2012
• |
• 11 Elul 5772
• |
• 1074 views

Related Classes

• 

  57 min

  Laws of Muktzeh on Shabbos -- Part 2

  The Five Categories of Muktzeh. Can I Move Frozen Pizza on Shabbos?

• 

  56 min

  The Laws of Muktzeh -- Part 3

  The Two Types of Utensils Regarding Muktzeh

• 

  49 min

  Laws of Muktzeh on Shabbos -- #4

  The Meaning of Muktzeh Because of Value -- "Chesron Kis"

• 

  57 min

  Laws of Muktzeh on Shabbos -- #5

  The Halachik Category of Inherent Muktzeh “Muktzeh Machamas Gufo” The status of raw food, money, wood, rocks, sand, and animals on Shabbos

• 

  52 min

  Laws of Muktzeh on Shabbos -- #6

  Removing Garbage and Disgusting Items. The dispensations made on Muktzeh to preserve human dignity

• 

  55 min

  The Laws of Muktzeh #7

  The Status of Objects Supporting Muktzeh Items “Basis L’davar Haasur”

• 

  55 min

  The Laws of Muktzeh #8

  The Laws of “Basis:” Objects Which Support Muktzeh Items. What’s the Halachik status of the Drawer or Pocket Containing Money?

• 

  48 min

  The Laws of Muktzeh #9

  The Status of the Candlesticks & the Shabbos Table

• 

  26 min

  The Laws of Muktzeh #10 -- Muktzeh Quiz

  Test your knowledge of the laws of Muktzeh on Shabbos