• M

  Anonymous -7 days ago

  For those of us with a keen sense of American history, seeing the "America First" logo between some of the most prominent rabbanim in America, most notably the great Rabbi YY, was jarring.  Hearing frum yiddin scream "4 more years" with that logo in the backgrop was likewise disturbing.  While President Trump may indeed be a far better president for the immediate needs and interests of the world of Torah jewry (I think that is clear, given what has transpired on the left), his very personality, personal morality, aversion to truth, promoting personal attacks on others, etc., makes it a busha for such major talmudei chachamim to full-throatedly on a very public platform express adoring feelings for him.  I know this is not a popular opinion in our kehilla, especially while Israel is at war..   

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

  • Anonymous -7 days ago

    https://fpif.org/the-ugly-origins-of-trumps-america-first-policy/

    Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

• Y

  Yisroel -4 years ago

  Awesome

  I just read your Mishpacha Magazine article about the presidential fundraiser. I just felt the need to tell you that this was an unprecedented demonstration of Hakoras hatov and Kiddush Hashem.  

   

  it is unprecedented in history that it's specifically the ultra-orthodox Jews that have the ear of the leadership instead of other people. The president has gone out of his way to demonstrate his support for the Jewish community.

   

  It is so important that the ultra-orthodox community express their appreciation and support for our president and to continue to do so publicly.

   

  We may not be complacent about having friends in high places but we must recognize this unbelievable time that we are experiencing and utilize it for the betterment of all the Jewish people.

   

  Emails, letter writing and even calling the White House switchboard are all logged and documented are very important for creating a public record of a communal support for the president. This is something that should be promoted and encouraged continuously.

   

  מגלגלין זכות על ידי זכאי, אשרי חלקך שזכית לכך.

   

   

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

• S

  Shmuel -4 years ago

  What was your source for a beracha for seeing President Trump? Your brother brought down numerous sources that we don't, and according to the Alter Rebbe, that includes even without shem and malchus.

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

  • Anonymous -4 years ago

    There is an argument among rabbinic authorities whether or not this blessing is said for an elected president, who is not a monarch.

    I followed the many halachic opinions (the Shevet HaLevi, Rav Shmuel Wosner; the Shearim Metzuyanim B’Halachah, Rav Shlomo Zalman Braun; Ravi Dovid Yosef, and others) that the blessing should be made even on a president if he has the authority to commute a death sentence and can declare war.

    In addition, as the leader of the free world, the president of the United States has a unique status that increases the validity of making such a blessing.

    The Baal HaTanya, the Alter Rebbe (Seder Birchas Haneehenin, ch. 13) does quotes the Shlchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 224) verbatim, and does not negate Preisdents. However we explain the Shlchan Aruch, we can explain the Alter Rebbe, so there is no proof this way or that.

    On a side note, if I recall correctly, the Rebbe once shared with Rabbi Moshe Feller, that in Halacha he can rely on the Shearim Metzuyanim B’Halachah.

    Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

  • Anonymous -4 years ago

    There is an argument among rabbinic authorities whether or not this blessing is said for an elected president, who is not a monarch.

    I followed the many halachic opinions (the Shevet HaLevi, Rav Shmuel Wosner; the Shearim Metzuyanim B’Halachah, Rav Shlomo Zalman Braun; Ravi Dovid Yosef, and others) that the blessing should be made even on a president if he has the authority to commute a death sentence and can declare war.

    In addition, as the leader of the free world, the president of the United States has a unique status that increases the validity of making such a blessing.

    The Baal HaTanya, the Alter Rebbe (Seder Birchas Haneehenin, ch. 13) does quotes the Shlchan Aruch (Orach Chaim 224) verbatim, and does not negate Preisdents. However we explain the Shlchan Aruch, we can explain the Alter Rebbe, so there is no proof this way or that.

    On a side note, if I recall correctly, the Rebbe once shared with Rabbi Moshe Feller, that in Halacha he can rely on the Shearim Metzuyanim B’Halachah.

    Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

• CL

  CHANY LIGETI -4 years ago

  Thanx for showing our support

  Thank you so much Rabbi Jackobson for showing our support towards president trump with such beautiful words

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

• Anonymous -4 years ago

  Thanks to all for your candid feedback, please allow me to explain my position on this.

  I do not condone any behavior of any President that is wrong. I do not embrace unrefined language or any actions that are wanting, Yet the facts remain, that Donald Trump, notwithstanding all his flaws and shortcomings, canceled the horrific and dangerous Nuclear deal with Iran, a regime yearning to create a second Auschwitz, a despicable leadership which craves to see rivers of blood flowing—heaven forbid—from Jerusalem to Washington. He has been a staunch friend of Israel and the Jewish people. Despite radical pressure and criticism, he in contrast to many former Presidents who promised and did not deliver, relocated the US Embassy in Jerusalem. Under his leadership, the US acknowledged the Golan Heights as part of Israel. He commuted the sentence of Sholom Mordechai Rubashkin who did not deserve to sit 27 years in a prison cell. Does he not deserve a thank you?

  Israel is fighting now in Gaza. In the past, the US always called on both sides to show restraint. No more. The President knows the difference between terrorists and the victims of the terrorists—and he calls a spade a spade. He knows this is not a battle of two equal sides. This is a quantum shift in US policy toward Israel. Does he not deserve a thank you?

  The Palestinian Authority was giving billions of shekels a year to the families of ‘Sahids,’ who murdered Jews. In 2016, the PA distributed 303 million dollars in stipends to families of people who axed, stabbed and gunned down Jews—money coming from US taxpayers. The shameful tradition was happening both under Republican and Democratic presidents. Trump was the first leader who said no more. He stopped it. Does he not deserve a thank you?

  The President has made it a priority to fight and destroy terror groups and has worked hard to protect this country from terror. He says it the way it is and does not confuse the good guys with the evil monsters. Does he not deserve a thank you?

  It is not only about the past, but also about the future. He is the President of the US, no matter if one likes it or not. We, the Jewish people, want to use our influence to influence politicians to use their power to defend the good and the innocent, to fight anti-Semitism, to support Israel, to combat terrorism, to cut down ISIS and all other Islamists who crave to see a world drenched in the blood of infidels. How can we try to yield positive influence, if all we do is discuss the flaws of one leader or another, no matter whether true or false?

  In all honesty, do you think as a result of my words at the luncheon, the President might be friendlier to Israel or conversely? In the book of reality, that’s what matters to me: the safety and security of seven million of our brothers and sisters living in the Holy Land.

  Let’s even assume for a moment that you are correct in all of your accusations concerning the President. So what? In Judaism, we always show respect to the office of the presidency, no matter its leader. No other man than Reb Chanina ben Tradyon states in Pirkei Avos: “You must pray for the welfare of the government.” And he was referring to the vicious Roman Empire who tortured him to death! G-d commanded Moshe to show respect to Pharaoh, and Elijah to show respect to Achav—both vicious kings.

  Throughout history, Jews went to meet all types of leaders, of all shades and hues, for this exact reason: to help tip the scale to the good. Sometimes they met with leaders of very low moral standing; sometimes they met heinous and evil kings. The Talmud and Midrash are filled with these narratives. In the Tanach, Esther went to meet Achashverosh who killed his own queen and agreed to a genocidal plan of Haman, because she knew that G-d wants us to employ the natural means to influence leaders to try to do the right thing at the right moment.

  Even if you disagree, there is no need for you to box me into a primitive model just because I disagree with you on this issue. Instead of assuming abruptly that I mortgaged my soul, you can say: I disagree, but I can respect that maybe Rabbi YY was acting in good faith and trying to do the right thing, at least in his estimation. If you could not even entertain such a thought, I pray that you expand your horizons, and that your commitment to kindness, compassion, sensitivity, and decency is internalized by you even when judging someone who went to meet the President of the United States.

  That's one of the reasons it is important to learn Talmud. Every page of Talmud is full of debates and disputations; the sages argue about almost everything. Yet, always with respect and dignity. They do not vilify each other.

  Regardless, life moves on. The President went back to his business, and I went back to my business. It is time to resume our study of Torah, our dedication to prayer, our celebration of Mitzvos, and our work to turn our world into an abode for the Divine, a world filled with goodness, kindness, compassion and holiness.

  Respectfully, and with many warm blessings to all!

  YY Jacobson

  Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

  • Anonymous -4 years ago

    excellent response Rav YY.

    brocho vehatzlocho! 

    Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

  • S

    S.A. -4 years ago

    כמה נכון וכמה צודק!

    שכינה מדברת מתוך גרונך!

    תודה לרב ג'ייקובסון, לאחרונה יוצא לשמוע אותך הרבה ואני תמיד יוצא מחוזק מהדברים,

    תודה רבה! חיזקו ואימצו!

    Reply to this comment.Flag this comment.

America First Action Luncheon for Trump

Rabbi YY Jacobson

• November 12, 2019
• |
• 14 Cheshvan 5780
• |
• 11305 views

Related Classes

• 

  1 hr 46 min

  Yisro Women's Class/ Israel-Hamas War

  Why You Should Be a Proud Jew Today: Crash Course on Jewish History

  Three Truths that Inspired Yisro to Join Israel

• 

  Essay Parshas Vayishlach/Yud-Tes Kislev

  Are Jews the Chosen People?

  Why the Obsession with Israel and Jews?

• 

  9 min

  Conversation With Campus Students

  The Role of Jewish Students Today

  The Most Powerful Jewish Weapon

• 

  1 hr 1 min

  Rabbi YY on Instagram Live with Rabbi Rapps

  Is the 'Chosen People' Idea Racist? Do Non-Jews Go to Heaven?

  How the Seven Noahide Laws Can Transform Humanity

• 

  1 hr 28 min

  Zoom Lecture to European Jewish Students

  Why Celebrate Judaism in an Antisemitic World?

  Can Assimilation Solve the Problem of Jew-Hatred?

• 

  1 hr 46 min

  Address to College Students Mexico City

  How To Wear Judaism With Pride

  Tuesday, May 26, 9:30pm EST

• 

  1 hr 31 min

  Women's Vayishlach Class

  Can I Ever Make Peace with Myself?

  Can I Look You in the Eyes? Can I Look Myself in the Eyes? Can I Look G-d in the Eyes?

• 

  1 hr 5 min

  Lecture Sinai Indaba, Cape Town, South Africa

  The Epic Struggle of Jewish Identity

  Why do Many Jews Feel Uncomfortable with Themselves?

• 

  Women's Balak Class

  The Crouching Lion & the Tattooist of Auschwitz

  Why Did Rubashkin Not Go to Therapy? Can Jews Be Curbed?

• 

  Keynote at Banquet of Dallas Torah Day School

  Dallas Lecture: The Six Building Blocks of Jewish Identity

  1) Identity. 2) Freedom. 3) Values. 4) Family. 5) Independence. 6) Resilience.

• 

  44 min

  Terrorism/Antisemitism

  Murder at Chabad of Poway: A Bullet in the Soul of America

  We Must Revive the Conscience of Our Nation